Brussels and Geneva (CNN) President Joe Biden is using time away from summit meetings on his European tour this week for intense preparations ahead of his talks with Vladimir Putin, according to officials, as he works to avoid the pitfalls his predecessors faced in showdowns with the Russian leader.
Most of his formal meetings this week have started after noon, leaving his mornings free for consultations with advisers. He has held lengthy preparation sessions with senior officials, including Secretary of State Antony Blinken and national security adviser Jake Sullivan, to discuss the wide range of issues he plans to bring up with Putin, from cyberattacks to Syria to Ukraine.
The President has also asked foreign leaders at the G7, including German Chancellor Angela Merkel, for their input as he prepares for the meeting in Geneva, according to people familiar with the conversations. Putin even came up as a point of conversation during his tea with Queen Elizabeth II at Windsor Castle, Biden told reporters, saying she “wanted to know” about the Russian President.
Joe Biden preparing intensely for Putin’s tactics with aides and allies
Given some NATO allies had expressed concern about the optics of Biden’s summit with Putin, Sullivan said Biden would speak privately with leaders “about what he intends to talk to Putin about” during a meeting of the defense alliance on Monday. “He gets to hear from them as well, so that he will go into Geneva with the full support and solidarity of all of our NATO allies,” Sullivan told reporters on Air Force One Sunday, specifically highlighting Biden’s meeting with Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan on Monday as a chance to “compare notes.”
“Every world leader here that’s a member of NATO thanked me for meeting with Putin now. Every single one,” Biden said Monday in Brussels where he was attending a summit of the defense alliance. He said he’d found “a consensus and they thanked me for being willing to talk with them about the meeting and what I intended to do.”
The US President struck a tough tone while fielding questions from reporters after meeting with the alliance as well as a number of leaders one-on-one. NATO members, he said, must root out corruption and “guard against those who would stoke hatred and division for political gain as phony populism.”
It’s all part of the tense lead-up to Biden’s first sit-down with an American adversary during his time in office, and the scene in Switzerland is beginning to reflect the mood within the White House.
Security in Geneva is tightening ahead of the Wednesday summit. Parc La Grange, a park inside Geneva with an 18th century villa where the two leaders will be holding their meetings, has been completely closed to the public since last week and will remain so until at least Friday. Barbed wire has been set up along the perimeter of the park as well as along the street in some areas leading up to the park’s entrance.
Intense studying
As Biden becomes the fifth straight American president with whom Putin has met, officials want Biden to be prepared for Putin’s tactics, including his well-known habit of turning discussions of Russia’s bad practices back on the United States. Biden has told aides he believes Putin will respond to directness during their talks and wants to be ready to offer a frank message.
“He’s overprepared!” Biden’s wife, first lady Jill Biden, exclaimed last week when asked whether her husband was primed for his meeting with Putin.
Along with Merkel, Biden has opened the door for input to other key allies in bilateral meetings and conversations on the margins over the last several days. The idea serves dual purposes, aides said: While Biden’s decades in foreign policy give him aself-assurance about his approach, he sees value in the views of others who have had similar meetings with the Russian leader.
Biden also sees merit in allies feeling a part of his process, as he makes an effort to reassure them in his intentions while bringing them closer as part of a clear US effort to arrive at the Putin meeting after public displays of unity among Western allies, according to a person familiar with the process.
But officials say Biden is also preparing to discuss with Putin areas of potential mutual interest, laying out a potential pathway to move a relationship that he acknowledged Sunday was at a low point. There are obvious issues, ranging from Afghanistan and the Iran nuclear deal to the nuclear capabilities of both nations, where communication and a working relationship is considered critical.
But there are also more incremental steps Biden may propose to establish a baseline between a new administration and a long-standing foe, one person familiar with the preparation said. The goal isn’t any kind of dramatic breakthrough, and Biden and his aides alike have been careful to make clear there is no expectation of anything of the sort.
Instead, officials say Biden wants to consider smaller steps that would provide a signal as to whether a baseline can be established in the effort to move toward a more “stable and predictable” relationship, the current stated goal for Biden and his team.
Attempting to deny Putin a platform
Biden does not plan to hold a joint press conference with Putin following the summit, choosing instead to speak to reporters solo. Officials say Russia pushed for a joint press conference during negotiations about the summit. But the US resisted because they did not want to give Putin a platform like he had after a summit with President Donald Trump in Helsinki.
Officials also said they were mindful of Putin’s desire to appear like he’d gotten the better of a US president, and wanted to avoid a situation that devolved into a tit-for-tat playing out in public.
“This is not a contest about who can do better in front of a press conference or try to embarrass each other,” Biden said on Sunday, explaining the decision.
Biden will meet with Putin in two sessions, one a smaller group and one with a larger contingent of aides, according to a White House official.
It was still being worked out with the Russians what the exact composition of each meeting will be, or whether Biden would meet one-on-one with Putin without any notetakers present.
The preparation, and messaging surrounding the summit, has not been completely seamless. Some were surprised on Sunday when Biden seemed to suggest he would be open to an exchange of cyber criminals with Russia, a request Putin had made in an earlier interview with Russia’s state-run TASS news agency.
Asked during a press conference whether Biden would be “open to that kind of a trade with Vladimir Putin,”Biden responded in the affirmative: “Yes,” he said. “If there’s crimes committed against Russia, and the people committing those crimes are being harbored in the United States, I’m committing to holding them accountable.”
To the fierce Putin critic Bill Browder, the comment was reminiscent of Putin’s suggestion in 2018— during his joint press conference in Helsinki with Trump — that Russia might extradite criminals to the US if the US made Americans available to Russia for questioning, including Browder.
“I hope Biden isn’t planning to offer me up to Putin in Geneva in the same way that Trump did in Helsinki,” Browder wrote on Twitter, calling Biden’s remarks “a little worrying.”
Sullivan later tried to clarify Biden’s comments, saying the President “was not saying, ‘I’m going to exchange cyber criminals.'”
“What he was saying was that if Vladimir Putin wants to come and say, ‘I’m prepared to make sure that cyber criminals are held accountable,’ Joe Biden is perfectly willing to show up and say cyber criminals will be held accountable in America, because they already are,” he said.
Biden expected to deliver ‘some pretty tough messages’
The President has harbored a skeptical view of Putin for decades. After former President George W. Bush met with Putin in Slovenia in June 2001, Bush said he looked him in the eye and got “a sense of his soul.” Biden, then a senator and chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee, responded to those comments by saying, “I don’t trust Putin. Hopefully, the president was being stylistic rather than substantive.”
Biden has taken a large coterie of aides with him on his first foreign trip. He traveled with Blinken aboard Air Force One to Cornwall, though the secretary of state departed early for Brussels on his own plane. Also on the trip are Sullivan, who has staffed Biden in summit sessions.
Senior West Wing advisers Jen O’Malley Dillon, Mike Donilon and Bruce Reed are traveling with Biden, as are press secretary Jen Psaki and communications director Kate Bedingfield.
A number of National Security Council officials are also on the trip, including NSC chief of staff Yohannes Abraham, deputy national security adviser Daleep Singh, NSC senior director of speechwriting Carlyn Reichel and senior director for Europe Amanda Sloat.
The Wednesday summit between Biden and Putin — and its anticipated outcome — was the subject of considerable conversation among other leaders gathering for a meeting of their own at NATO Headquarters on Monday.
British Prime Minister Boris Johnson said Biden would “be taking some pretty tough messages to President Putin in the course of the next few days,” a comment suggesting that he, too, had discussed the summit with Biden during their back-to-back days of receptions and sessions that he hosted on the first part of Biden’s journey.
Joe Biden Attends Sunday Mass in English Seaside Town Amid G7 Summit
Catholics in the English seaside town of St. Ives, Cornwall, were surprised Sunday to find the President of the United States at Mass in their parish church.
Joe Biden and First Lady Jill Biden attended the 9 a.m. Mass on June 13 at Sacred Heart and St. Ia Church, southwest England, on the final day of the G7 summit at Carbis Bay.
Biden, America’s second Catholic President after John F. Kennedy, and his wife spent around 30 minutes at the church amid tight security.
The celebrant Canon Philip Dyson told the PA news agency that the couple’s presence made him feel slightly nervous.
“It’s the President of the United States of America,”he said. “It’s a great occasion to welcome him into our parish, into the church, and it’s lovely to know he made the time in his busy schedule in order to come to Mass.”
Father Dyson told PA that he had a short conversation with Biden at the end of Mass.
“I welcomed him to Cornwall and he said he was enjoying his time here and there were many serious matters they were discussing and just hope it’s going to come to fruition,” he said.
The priest added that the Scripture readings for the day were fitting as they concerned “creation and climate, and things growing.”
The G7 leaders have agreed to increase efforts to tackle climate change and renewed a promise to raise $100 billion a year to help developing nations cut emissions.
Father Dyson stressed that the day’s readings were not selected “by choice.”
“It’s just the way it always is. The word of God always fits in,” he said.
The canon is pastor of the parish of the Holy Family, which encompasses several local Catholic churches, including the Sacred Heart and St. Ia, within the Diocese of Plymouth. St. Ia was an evangelist from Ireland who died as martyr in Cornwall in the fifth or sixth century.
A parishioner told the Associated Press that she was “gobsmacked” to see the Bidens at Mass in the town with a population of around 12,000 people.
“It’s quite amazing, we went into the church and they took some details from us and I thought this is a bit unusual,” said Annie Fitzpatrick.
“About 10 minutes into the service the doors opened up and President Biden and Dr. Jill Biden walked in and just sat in the pew just across from me.”
The reports did not touch on whether Biden received Holy Communion — a topic of considerable controversy given his stance on abortion.
According to the parish newsletter, the Mass intention was for the G7 summit.
The newsletter included an appeal to the congregation to contact their local MP to urge the U.K. government to revoke a temporary measure allowing women up to 10 weeks pregnant to take both abortion pills at home. The measure was introduced atthe start of the coronavirus pandemic.
Another parishioner told the AP that Biden appeared to make a “very generous donation” to the church before he left.
As he exited, Biden described the church as “beautiful.”
NATO Places China Firmly in Its Sights As Joe Biden Strengthens Alliance
NATO leaders are expected to issue a statement criticizing China after their meeting in Belgium on Monday, as U.S. President Joe Biden strengthens his alliance with the intergovernmental organization.
Members of NATO, a military alliance between 30 European and North American countries that was set up in 1949 following World War II, met on Monday in Brussels, in what was Biden’s first meeting with the group since becoming president.
Diplomats told Reuters that the summit’s final statement on Monday would refer to China as a “systemic” challenge to the safety of NATO members, but would refrain from describing it as an “adversary.”
Reuters reported that the group’s members have become concerned with China’s military rise and increasing closeness with Russia. Russia is not a member of NATO, but joined its Partnership for Peace program in 1994.
Ahead of Monday’s meeting, Jake Sullivan, U.S. national security adviser, revealed that China “will feature in the communique in a more robust way than we’ve ever seen before.”
Biden told reporters after arriving at the summit that “there is a growing recognition over the last couple years that we have new challenges. We have Russia, which is acting in a way that is not consistent with what we had hoped, and we have China.”
The sentiment was also echoed by UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson, who said: “When it comes to China, I don’t think anybody around the table wants to descend into a new Cold War with China.”
NATO’s expected statement will follow criticism of China from leaders including Biden and Johnson at the G7 Summit that took place last Friday to Sunday. The pair, alongside other members, said that there needs to be a transparent investigation into the origins of COVID-19 in the country and accused it of engaging in human rights abuses in Xinjiang and Hong Kong.
Responding to the criticism, the Chinese embassy in London said that “China’s reputation must not be slandered” and called the mentions of Xinjiang and Hong Kong “sinister intentions of a few countries such as the United States.”
Biden’s appearance at the summit on Monday should strengthen the U.S. relationship with NATO, after the organization’s ties with the country weakened during former President Donald Trump’s time in office.
During Trump’s presidency, he criticized the amount of funding the U.S. was providing to NATO, as he complained that allies, particularly Germany, did not spend the stipulated membership amount of 2 percent of their defense budget on the group. All of the members have committed to that figure by 2024.
Reports swirled in 2018 that Trump was threatening to pull out of NATO. He canceled a planned press conference at the summit in 2019, as tensions rose between the U.S. and the 29 other countries with membership of the organization.
However, Biden took a different approach on Monday, as he confirmed that under his leadership, the U.S. will be committed to NATO.
“I want to make it clear: NATO is critically important for U.S. interests,” Biden said as he arrived at the summit on Monday.
He went on to say that the U.S. has a “sacred obligation” to observe Article 5 of NATO’s founding treaty, which commits members to defend each other from attack, and told NATO’s secretary-general Jens Stoltenberg: “I want NATO to know America is there.”
