The most common misconception is that portable structures and modular buildings are the same. Although they are both prefabricated structures in a technical sense, they are not the same thing–from designs and construction processes to usage.
To know more about how these two really differ from one another, below are 4 mains differences you might want to consider:
Design and Construction
Modular Buildings
In a factory, modular structures are built in pieces or modules off-site. A whole structure is erected on location by carefully transporting each module. These constructions are adaptable and efficient, with the option to be permanent or semi-permanent in design.
The off-site building method minimises site disturbance and cuts down on waste. There are many uses for modular construction, such as in commercial, residential, and educational settings.
They are becoming increasingly popular in the construction business due to their versatility and faster construction schedule, which offer a sustainable and affordable alternative to conventional building methods.
Portable Buildings
Portable structures, often referred to as mobile or relocatable buildings, are made to be easily moved from one area to another. Because they are made as a single item and can be carried in their whole, setup is quick and easy.
Compared to modular buildings, these structures frequently have simpler designs, which increases their adaptability and versatility. Temporary workspaces including schools, offices, and storage facilities are frequently housed in portable structures.
They are perfect for a variety of temporary applications since they are simple to put up and carry. Additionally, for those in need of temporary constructions without the permanency of typical buildings, portable buildings provide an affordable and adaptable option.
Transportation and Installation
Modular Buildings
Because each modular construction module needs to be carried individually and constructed on-site, the logistics of transportation for these structures are more intricate. This procedure makes it possible to create buildings that are larger and more individualised to meet certain requirements and tastes.
But to guarantee the effective delivery and installation of every module, careful planning and coordination are required. Skilled labour is required during on-site assembly to seamlessly join the modules, guaranteeing both structural integrity and visual attractiveness.
Modular structures provide several benefits, even with the additional complexity and installation time. These benefits include shorter construction times, less disturbance on the job site, and improved quality control because of the factory-controlled production environment.
Because of their adaptable design, they may be used in a variety of settings, including commercial and residential structures as well as healthcare and educational institutions.
Portable Buildings
Complete portable structures are made to be easily transported. They frequently require little setup on-site and may be swiftly supplied and set up at the location. This makes them perfect for short-term applications like storage, workplaces, and education. They offer an affordable and adaptable solution for a range of temporary demands because of its straightforward design and simplicity of transportation.
Durability and Usage
Modular Buildings
Long-term usage and resistance to challenging environmental conditions are features of modular structures. Applications needing permanent buildings, such as offices, classrooms, or modular healthcare buildings/facilities, are perfect for them.
Their sturdy design guarantees stability and longevity, making them appropriate for a variety of environments. Furthermore, compared to traditional buildings, modular buildings have faster construction timelines and more design flexibility, making them a dependable and effective long-term option.
Portable Buildings
Temporary or brief needs, such as construction site offices, makeshift classrooms, event areas, or temporary housing, are usually served by portable buildings. Although they might not be as sturdy as modular structures, they provide a great deal of mobility flexibility.
They are a well-liked option for many transient applications due to their simplicity of setup and transportation, offering a practical and effective alternative.
Customization
Modular Buildings
Significant customisation flexibility is provided by modular structures, enabling them to satisfy certain functional and architectural needs. Larger buildings may be constructed by combining many modules, which makes them appropriate for a variety of uses.
Because of their flexible design, they may be used for a variety of purposes, including institutional, commercial, and residential ones. Because of their adaptability, modular structures are a great option for projects that need scalable and customised solutions.
Portable Buildings
The designs of portable buildings are frequently standardised, with little room for customisation. Designed with shared functions in mind, their adaptability to specific demands may be limited.
They are perfect for short-term applications like temporary offices or classrooms because of their ease of use and speedy setup, but they don’t have the flexibility that more permanent construction options provide.
Take away
In conclusion, although both modular and portable structures provide prefabricated solutions for different uses, the decision between them is mostly based on elements like the intended use, the length of the project, the degree of customisation required, and logistical concerns.
